With 8 game projects selected for the 19th Hangzhou Asian Games e-sports event, as an important part of the digital content industry, new formats such as e-sports, game live broadcast and game short video will help the digital content industry to prosper. Especially with the implementation of the new "Copyright Law", as the "source of living water" for the development of the game industry chain, game copyright protection has reached a new level.
On November 13, the Online Game Copyright Work Committee of the China Copyright Association and the Institute of Intellectual Property and Competition Law of Shanghai Jiaotong University jointly held a seminar on the protection of online games in the context of the new Copyright Law, and released the Annual Report on Game Copyright 2020- 2021" (hereinafter referred to as "Report").
The "Report" believes that with the continuous launch of China's original high-quality games, the legalization of game content has become the consensus of participants in the entire game industry chain, and the importance of building a benign game copyright ecology has become increasingly prominent. The new "Copyright Law" uniformly names "works with continuous pictures as the form of expression" as "audiovisual works" to provide more flexible legal protection for the copyright of game content. At the same time, the clarification of applicable laws and the unification of judicial adjudication standards have effectively improved the quality and effectiveness of the trial of game copyright cases, and effectively strengthened the copyright protection of online games and their derivative industries.
Kong Xiangjun, the dean of Kaiyuan Law School of Shanghai Jiaotong University and the dean of the Institute of Intellectual Property and Competition Law, said that the new "Copyright Law" has made some new regulations on the scope of protection of works and types of works, and the corresponding system has been further improved. In recent years, the protection of online games has received much attention because the online game industry is very important and an important part of the digital content industry chain. At the same time, industry demand promotes legal protection, and the revision of the new "Copyright Law" provides more and greater possibilities for online game protection.

The copyright value of online games continues to increase, and the revenue from IP adaptation games exceeds 100 billion yuan
In the early morning of November 7, EDG won the championship and renewed the attention to the copyright value of e-sports events. On the night when EDG won the championship, data from the live broadcast platform of the "League of Legends" S11 finals showed that the cumulative popularity of live broadcasts on platforms such as Station B, Douyu and Huya exceeded 500 million.
At the same time, the e-sports event was officially selected for the Asian Games. On November 5th, the Hangzhou Asian Organizing Committee announced that "League of Legends", "King of Glory (Asian Games Edition)", "Peace Elite (Asian Games Edition)", "Heartstone Legend", "Dota2", "Dream Three Kingdoms 2", " Eight events of Street Fighter 5 and FIFA Online 4 were selected for the 19th Hangzhou Asian Games e-sports events, and the medals won by the events will be included in the national medal list. This also marks that e-sports has been incorporated into the competition system by international competitions and has become a widely recognized competitive sport.
The vigorous development of the e-sports market is closely related to the continuous increase in the copyright value of online games. The data shows that the game industry market has reached 278.6 billion yuan, of which, China's e-sports market revenue has increased from 94.727 billion yuan in 2019 to 136.557 billion yuan in 2020, a year-on-year increase of 44.16%.
The report believes that the integration of multiple formats with online game content as the core has become a new development trend. In 2020, the revenue of mobile games adapted from IP will exceed 100 billion yuan for the first time, and gaming IP has become an important driving force supporting the growth of the mobile game market. According to gamma statistics, representative game IPs have developed IP linkages in areas such as film and television, FMCG, culture, games, and animation, among which 78% of IPs have developed IP linkages in at least three areas.

The combination of game content, live broadcast and video has created emerging derivative industries such as game live broadcast and short game video. The report pointed out that in recent years, the duration of game users' pan-gaming behavior has increased significantly, and the status of game live broadcast and short game video in the game industry chain has been continuously improved. Among them, game content is the basic element for the construction of game live broadcast and game video industry. Regardless of whether it is game users or game platforms that simply record and upload or edit to form game videos, or game users and anchors conduct game live broadcasts, they all rely on game copyright owners to provide corresponding game content materials.
At the same time, the report believes that game live broadcasts and game short videos are still integrated with game products in terms of user groups and functions. Game products not only provide core entertainment content for game live broadcasts and short game videos, but also bring them a lot of user resources.
Game industry legislative policies are improving day by day, and judicial adjudication standards are unified
With the help of game live broadcasts and short game videos derived from game content, it forms an upstream and downstream relationship with the copyright of online games. At the same time, issues involving the balance of commercial interests among different business types have also aroused the attention of judicial administration and industry associations.
In judicial trials, the exploration of new rules for game copyright protection has continued to deepen. The report believes that at present, the judicial system forms a mode of coexistence of split protection and overall protection of game copyrights. The right holder can claim that the separated game elements constitute a work and require corresponding protection, or claim that the continuous dynamic picture of the game constitutes a movie work and obtain the protection of the copyright law.
In addition, the legislative policy system involving the online game industry is becoming more and more perfect. The report believes that the new "Copyright Law" is revised, "audiovisual works" replace "film works and works created in a similar way to filming films", canceling the latter's technical requirements for "filming", and has a broader coverage. Game live images and live images are continuous dynamic images, which meet the requirements of "audiovisual works" and can be included for protection. Under the new "Copyright Law", the original dispute about the protection of game live broadcast screens will be solved.
The report pointed out that in response to the need for protection of new copyright objects arising from the reform of information technology, the new Copyright Law breaks the closed enumeration regulations of work types, introduces a punitive damages system, greatly increases the statutory compensation amount, and sets a minimum infringement compensation standard, all of which are legislation. A clear response to online piracy.
Professor Cong Lixian of the School of Intellectual Property of East China University of Political Science and Law believes that most of the online game works are created, designed, and coded by game developers and computer software developers, and the developers have the right ownership of course. The fair use system is a specific situation that should be used with caution. For the use of online game works, if it constitutes conversion use, it constitutes fair use, which does not conform to the principle of copyright law for hundreds of years. The rise of one industry cannot be done at the expense of another industry. The same is true.
In addition, many local courts have issued trial guidelines to unify adjudication standards for online game intellectual property cases. The report believes that the development of the game industry requires macro-industry regulations and protections, clarifying the rules of law application from the judicial level, and unifying judicial judgment standards, which will help to properly handle game copyright infringement disputes. From the local courts to the Supreme People's Court, the clear application of laws and the unification of judicial judgment standards have effectively improved the quality and effectiveness of the trial of game copyright cases, and effectively strengthened the copyright protection of online games and their derivative industries.
The report pointed out that the stakeholders in the game content ecology should reach a consensus to improve the copyright awareness of users and the game content ecology stakeholders. It should be clear that unauthorized game live broadcasts, short videos, etc. will face infringement issues and be punished. Derivative industries that develop based on game content should actively sign agreements with game copyright owners, obtain authorizations and agree on reasonable profit distribution methods, jointly explore copyright authorization principles that are more in line with industry practices and clearer, and promote more dynamic and healthy game copyrights Establishment of authorization rules.
Copyright filtering technology urgently needs to be expanded and applied, and multiple parties have increased the regulation of account rental and sale of gray products
In the development of the online game industry, obstacles have also emerged one after another. Among them, frequent infringements and piracy, the gray industrial chain of game account rental and sale have attracted attention.
Regarding the chaotic phenomenon of online game account rental and sales, both regulatory agencies, judicial organs, and online game companies are heavily regulating. On August 30, the State Press and Publication Administration issued the ``Notice on Further Strict Management and Practically Preventing Minors from Indulging in Online Games'' requiring all games to be connected to the online game anti-addiction real-name verification system of the State Press and Publication Administration, and online game companies shall not Provide game services to users who have not registered and logged in with real names in any form.
Internet information departments and judicial organs are also continuing to regulate the lease and sale of ash products on online game accounts. On September 28, the People's Court of Kaifu District, Changsha City, Hunan Province issued the country's first ban on game rental platform. On October 18th, the National Cyberspace Administration of China held a national video work conference on "Clearness · Internet User Account Operation Disorder Special Action", and proposed to keep a close eye on five types of account operation chaos, including renting and selling online game accounts to minors .
Yang Xiaoling, President of the Intellectual Property Tribunal of the People's Court of Chongqing Liangjiang New District (Free Trade Zone), believes that online games contain comprehensive rights or benefits such as intellectual property rights and operation and management. The fundamental basis for At present, most of the relevant judicial precedents are judged in accordance with the network service contract. The agreement between game operators and players on the ownership of virtual property and the validity of the clauses prohibiting virtual goods transactions shall be recognized in principle, provided that they do not violate the legal rules of the format clauses and the consumer rights protection system. At the same time, online game service platforms have legal obligations to maintain network security, protect the legal rights and interests of minors, protect personal information, and prohibit the provision of legal currency reverse exchange. In order to fulfill these obligations, the prohibition of virtual property transactions by game operators is compulsory in fulfilling the law. Sex regulations.
Yang Xiaoling believes that when game operators prohibit virtual item transactions, whether third-party platforms provide users with game accounts and virtual item transactions constitute unfair competition. It should be based on "competitive relations, behavioral legitimacy, whether it disrupts the order of market competition, Injury the lawful rights and interests of other operators or consumers and constitute substantive competition damage. If necessary, economic analysis should be introduced to assess whether the core interests of the game operation are harmed. The act of providing transactions on third-party platforms distorted the resource allocation function of the market mechanism, interfered with the operation of game companies, and undermined the innovation incentives of the market mechanism. To a certain extent, the supply of virtual items on third-party platforms has replaced the game's incentive system. It cannot stimulate the development of game products, and it is difficult to improve market competitiveness. For free-to-play players, the emergence of gold makers in the third-party trading platform leads to the increase of virtual currency and props in the game, and the player's game experience will deteriorate, and even lead to the decline of the game, which will damage the interests of consumers in the long run.
In addition to online game accounts renting and selling ash products, the online game copyright industry is also facing the chronic problem of piracy and infringement. The report pointed out that technical means are gradually being used in the field of game copyright to help protect the copyright of game content. Technological innovation has enabled the realization of management methods that were once technically impossible. Some copyright fields have achieved high-strength rights protection in terms of right determination, right use and right maintenance through technical means.
At present, many Internet platforms at home and abroad apply copyright filtering technology to their products or software to achieve the effect of preventing infringement incidents, reducing governance costs, and maintaining normal copyright order. Among them, the YouTube website has been using Content ID, a content identification system, since 2007. By establishing a genuine database, scanning the videos uploaded by users at the same time, and supplemented by manual review to review the copyright content.
Feng Xiaoqing, a professor at the School of Civil, Commercial and Economic Law of China University of Political Science and Law, believes that certain online platforms need to bear more technical filtering and pre-screening responsibilities, and conduct pre-examination of infringements, instead of passive notification of deletion. The "safe harbour principle" (ie, the "notice-delete" rule) also has its limitations. Short videos, as audiovisual works, pose many challenges to the subject of rights, subjects of infringement, and even evidence of infringement. In the determination of infringement, a large number of short video infringements have passed The safe harbor principle evades liability, its effectiveness is questionable and has its limitations.

